Texas – The Ultimate FAIL


Texas science teachers will no longer be required to teach weaknesses of scientific theory, including evolution, under new curriculum standards tentatively adopted by the Board of Education Thursday.

The requirements were approved Friday by the State Board of Education in a 13-2 vote adopting new state science curriculum standards that will be in place for the next decade.

In a compromise plan, teachers will be required to have students scrutinize “all sides” of scientific theories, a move criticized by evolution proponents.

The vote caps a week of impassioned debate that had scientists, teachers and textbook publishers from around the country focused on Texas.

Supporters of evolution hailed the vote but were critical of amendments adopted by the board that they said could create new paths to teaching creationism and the similar theory of intelligent design in public schools.

If given final approval in a vote expected Friday, the new standards will drop a 20-year-old rule that requires both “strengths and weaknesses” of all scientific theories to be taught. Critics say the requirement is used to undermine the theory of evolution in favor of religious teachings.

The new standards, which would be in place for the next decade, govern what appears on standardized tests and material published in textbooks. As one of the largest textbook purchasers in the nation, Texas has significant influence over the content of books marketed across the country.

“Publishers are waiting to hear what to put in their textbooks,” said Dan Quinn, a spokesman for the watchdog group Texas Freedom Network.

In approving a handful of amendments Thursday, the board “slammed the door on creationism, then ran around the house opening up all the windows to let it in another way,” Quinn said. “We hope the vote tomorrow will reverse a lot of that.”

In one amendment, the board agreed to require high school biology students to “analyze and evaluate the sufficiency or insufficiency of natural selection to explain the complexity of the cell.”

Board member Don McLeroy said his amendment was intended “to account for that amazing complexity. I think it’s a standard that makes it honest with our children.”

Federal courts have ruled against teaching public schools teaching creationism and intelligent design, which holds that life is so complex that it must have come from an intelligent higher power.


From Physorg.com


2 thoughts on “Texas – The Ultimate FAIL

  1. I’d have to read the bills – with all of their attached amendments – to truly comment intelligently on this post. If you have links to such documents, they’d be appreciated – by people n both sides of the argument.

    From what you’ve written it sounds like a set of rulings that I would favor. Evolution, as set forth by the atheists, is just a theory and alternatives to some of its underlying precepts should be mentioned at least.

    Of course the older law of “requiring the teaching of the weaknesses of scientific theories” should have been sufficient for that.

    As I said, I’d have to read the bills in question…We don’t need Creationism taught as science, but we shouldn’t hold science as absolute either.

  2. Sorry, I refuse to bend in my belief that intelligent design (aka creationism) has any business being taught in science classrooms. It is thoroughly disappointing that in the most scientifically advanced nation in the world, creationists can still persuade politicians, judges and ordinary citizens that evolution is a flawed, poorly supported fantasy. These individuals continue to lobby for creationist ideas such as “intelligent design” to be taught as alternatives to evolution in science classrooms. Proponents of the intelligent-design theory only seek to use it as a wedge for reopening science classrooms to discussions of God.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s